Bagelicious II

Reviews

• Cece W.

  star star star star star 8 June 2026

  My husband and I tried Bagelicious II on a whim this weekend and loved it so much; we came back the next morning for breakfast.
  Our first time there, we went the drive-through route which was surprisingly quick for the line we spotted inside as we drove in. My husband got a poppy seed bagel with cream cheese (toasted) and I got a plain bagel with egg, cheese and turkey. The bagels were ready super quick and for a sandwich, his bagel and two juices, we only spent $14.
  The bagels are the most perfect bagels I have eaten in a long, long time. They are crispy on the outside without being too hard and inside, they are soft and bouncy without being that dense and chewy consistency of a Dunkin bagel.
  This morning, my husband got a turkey and cheese on a bagel and I got a french toast bagel with cream cheese. Both were phenomenal (again) and despite a long line inside, the drive through was nice and quick.
  We have definitely found our new bagel spot on the weekends!

• Elizabeth A.

  star star star star star_border 3 June 2026

  I wish Yelp allowed for half stars because I would give a 3.5.
  
  I have visited this location on several occasions and unfortunately what they lack is consistency. On my last visit, my sandwich was absolutely delicious! It was layered and packed full of egg, bacon and avocado. The bagel was nicely toasted and fresh. On my visit today, I can't say the same. Not only was the price different today for the same sandwich, it was no where near as full as the last time and the bagel was barely toasted. While I understand they have several staff members making sandwiches, it would be nice to get the same sandwich and price each visit.

• Johnny K.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  Stopped in a few times for coffee and a bite to eat with some old friends as it's a centrally located and interesting place....
  Every time we ordered, mistakes made, pricing wrong, cmon really?
  If you go pay attention at the register....

• Cliff P.

  star star star star star 20 May 2026

  Get place for a morning bagel or afternoon sandwich - so clean, so friendly....always a pleasure to see Donna's smiling face there to great you.
  Everything is so fresh - you can taste the difference and the coffee is excellent.  Not a franchise, family run - okay some said you have to wait a little longer, but remember you are no receiving processed food - everything here is made to order by quality people....great staff and they care. So slow down and enjoy....you're worth it !

• Robert R.

  star star star star star 18 May 2026

  If America runs in Dunkin, I would be happy if North Haven runs on Bagelicious.
  
  My 5 year old daughter said this morning, in between big bites of her blueberry bagel, "You know why they call it Bagelicious, because they make bagels that are DEEELICIOUS."
  
  We really enjoy Bagelicious. Their bagels are excellent and their breakfast sandwiches are really good. The other Bagelicious uses a scrambled egg for their breakfast sandwiches, which is ok but not my personal favorite. At the North Haven spot they make fried eggs and it makes a far superior sandwich.
  
  I go here with my kids on the weekend and they love it too. As long as you aren't in a crazy rush, service can be a little slow. Not terribly slow, just not the super fast paced response time of the donut shop conglomerates of New England, totally worth the short wait. With that said it's still one of the best places in town for a warm bagel or a sandwich.
  
  I will also say that they sell day old bagels a dozen at a time for $3.99 which seems like a heck of a deal to me. A toasted Bagelicious bagel that's a few days old is still better than most other bagels anywhere. I drop off a few to my grandma, and I still have bagels for breakfast all week.